Friday, September 21, 2018

What Defines Life ?

Kaiden says that someday A.I. may make so robots could be defined as being alive.  Ben disagrees saying that technology could not meet the characteristic of life. Who do you think is right and why do you agree with that person? 


58 comments:

Malayna said...

I agree with Ben because robots can't reproduce.

Anonymous said...

BEN is right robots cant be alive

Anonymous said...

idk

caitlyn b said...

i agree with ben cause robots cant reproduce

Anonymous said...

kaiden

Kayla said...

I dont think a robot should ever be classified as alive because they will just start doing everything fo us and we will get fat and humans work are for these robots to be on this earth they don't reproduce

Anonymous said...

no, i do not think that AI will be classified as an living thin because it has no cells.

Anonymous said...

I don't think that robots can someday be defined as a life form, because the can't reproduce and they don't have cells

Anonymous said...

i agree with ben because technology can not have cells because its mostley made out of metal

Abbey Laney said...

I agree with Ben because they don't have cells.

Helena SS said...

I agree with Ben because robots don't have cells or reproduce.

Paige A said...

I think they are not alive because they don't have cells but they do respond to stimuli and they can eat and evolve .

Amber M. said...

I agree with both, because the robots have some characteristics of life, but they don't have as many as living things.

Amber Rose Lemieux said...

If Ben disagrees with Kaiden saying that technology could not meet the characteristic of life, I agree with him because ROBOTS wouldn't have any of the things that humans have.

Anonymous said...

I agree with ben because he doesn't meet the characteristics of life.

Anonymous said...

I think no because it doesnt have cells and it can be hacked because itis tehnolagy

Sara Tracy said...

i agree with ben because a robot is not made of cell so it can't be alive.

Anonymous said...

Miranda Dearborn

I agree with ben because, robots can not reproduce and also they don't have any cells.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Ben robots don't have cells and they cant reproduce so they're not living.

Anonymous said...

no they cannot be alive because they do not have feelings and they do not have the 5 charteristics of life to become a living thing

Skippy PB said...

I think yes because of how rapidly technology is evolving also sooner or later metal might be able to expand so robots can grow

Charlie F. said...

I agree with Ben because although some robots meet most of the characteristics of life, they don't meet all of them like reproducing. They can make robots but they can't birth them. Also some robots might not have any cells.

Bakerman said...

BAKERMAN NOPE BECAUSE WE DONT WANT OUR VENDING MACINES TO BECOME TERMINATORS IMAGE WHAT WE COULD DO WITH THE FOOD IN SIDE THE VENDING MACINES IT COULD BE FUEL TO THEM

Anonymous said...

ben is right robots cant be alive because they have no feeling cells or any characteristics of life.

Taylor F. said...

I think it wouldn't be considered alive because even though they would make it fit to the characteristics of life, its still a robot. It wasn't really born.

Anonymous said...

Audrey...

Technology could not meet the characteristic of life because they not have anything that humans have

Anonymous said...

They might they might not you know I think maybe someday we will have robots and clones wade on us hand and foot one day.

Anonymous said...

idk

Meredith s. said...

I don't think it would be possible for a robot to be alive. Because first they would take over the world, Also they would not be able to reproduce, Even if they put a humans brain into a robot it still wouldn't be alive because it wouldn't reproduce or grow. So no I don't think it would be possible.

Meredith S

Grace L. said...

I agree with Ben! Even if a robot can move he could never have all the characteristics of life. If you put a human brain in a robot that still would not be alive because it can not grow.

Anonymous said...

i agree with ben because they cant reproduce

Mr. Robot said...

Kaiden! Robots will take over

Sofi D said...

i agree with ben because robots dont have a 8 characteristics of life.

Anonymous said...

I dissagree because even though it will have a brain and feel everything a humman feels it still cant reproduce or grow

Anonymous said...

i agree with ben because the brain cant grow if you put it into a robot body

zach brown said...

ben is right they cant become alive

Anonymous said...

I agree with Ben because it doesnt meet all 8 charestics of life

Unknown said...

Emerson,
I agree with Ben that a robot will never be able to have all the human characteristics of life.

Anonymous said...

kaiden, if they could replicate life at a cellular level and mimic other quilitys of life

Anonymous said...

I agree with Kaden if the ai was made by Apple

Anonymous said...

I agree with Ben because robots do not meet the characteristics of life.

Anonymous said...

I agree with ben because robots don't have the same characteristics of a human.

Anonymous said...

I disagree because the cells from the brain would have a hard time to navigate through the wires and carbon fiber. The wires could be frayed and exposed to water causing the A.I. to get catch fire.

Anonymous said...

i agree with ben because if they were alive they would be classified as organisms not robots

Corey H said...

I agree with Ben because robots can't meet all the characteristics of life and be living.

Kaylee said...

I agree with ben be because they don't have cells or any human traits

Anonymous said...

i agree with ben because it does not have the 8 characteristics of life

johnny lee roseman said...

i agree with ben because robots cant create life but can also save life

Jayden M said...

ben is right because the robots can't reproduce and the brain needs blood.

Gracey Hood said...

I agree with Ben, robots cannot be alive. Robots do not have blood, cells, a heart, lungs etc. Robots don't learn like us they only know what they have been programmed to. Humans can also eat and swim robots on the other hand don't have a digestion system, can't swim because they're made up of wires.

Anonymous said...

i think the answer is no because they dont have cells

Anonymous said...

i agree with ben because robots cant grow reproduce and respond to stimuli so in that case a robot cant be a human.

Anonymous said...

I think that a robot is not alive because it doesn't have the characteristics of life like cells, tissue ect mabye technology could be advanced well enough to give it some sort of personality but its not alive its a human resembling robot

Anonymous said...

I agree with Ben because robots cant reproduce

Raquel.s said...

ben is right robots cant be alive even if your tried

🤪Kk said...

I think that a robot could never be a live it does not have a heart or cells it can't breath air
and it can't grow and develop

Halyley said...

i agree with Ben because robots do not have some of the aspects of humans do like the blood flow and the eating abilities like we have.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Ben because it doesn't grow and develop. -Kaiden Tillman